“It’s a complex discipline, but it’s not a science. We just need people to just get around the same table, basically.” That’s Tom Denford’s simplified explanation of the emerging communications planning field. Denford, JWT’s Director of Communications Planning, explored the shifting dynamic between creative and media groups and discussed the changing face of comprehensive brand communications in a recent Q-and-A with Brand Connections CEO, Brian F Martin.
Not long ago, many marketers viewed full-service ad firms as the true keepers of the brand – partly because of high turnover among Chief Marketing Officers. Today’s widening media mix has become more important to the strategic communications plan, and it’s part of the reason more firms began to divide the creative and media buying tasks in the last decade. That’s where Denford, and the communications planning buzz, enter the picture. Having started his career as a media buyer and going on to work with nearly every major holding company in the media sector in London, JWT hopes Denford will help mend the splintered relationship between the creative and media buying groups.
Still, Denford says he doesn’t want to revert back to the full-service days. “I think there were inherent problems in the full-service mentality, which led people to be too focused on their own agendas as an agency. What we have now, actually, is a great place because we have lots of specialist companies, sort of experts within their individual fields, and we are now trying to create a type of culture that gets all of those disciplines together.” If the goal of Denford’s discipline is unity, the mindset to achieve it might be best characterized as one of collaboration.
Communications planning also requires a new way of thinking, according to Denford, where advertising is not necessarily the answer to every equation. “You go into a communications planning discussion on the basis that the output is not necessarily going to be advertising. It’s going to be communications, and it’s considering the way an advertiser’s brand communicates with the world, and you have to take into consideration all the elements that make that up.” In that way, he stresses the importance of solving business problems and understanding the role that communications plays in achieving those ends.
“Advertising may be the solution,” Denford says, “but there are so many other different weapons at our disposal and channels with which a brand can communicate with its consumers and future consumers. We need to embrace all of those. Part of a communications planner’s roles is making sure you’re considering all the right channels and that all of those channels are equally represented. That you have an environment of neutrality… It’s finding the right mix of all of these different channels, and that’s really the core skill of the communications planning discipline, getting the right blend of all of these different channels and coordinating them.”
Creative and media agencies appear to be receiving the message that they need to improve their relationship, and Denford says the client process is now often inhibiting a true collaboration across all these different agencies. He cites budget issues and a silo effect on the client side as problems, faulting horizontal dialogue across a team as insufficient. Denford believes clients should ask agencies what their communications processes are, and he emphasizes that all marketing agencies should all be thinking about how they can be collaborating together. He also says that media agencies need “to be more independent and organize their businesses to be more media neutral.”
The final trick of picking the media mix remains, however, where the TV v. non-TV debate rages on. Further muddying the waters are newcomers such as You Tube and TiVo. “Some things call for TV solutions but it shouldn’t be a start point, it should be just one of the many options available to you,” Denford says. Partially abandoning the known quantity of television requires courage, he acknowledges, but it’s not a risk devoid of rewards.
“We all have to be a bit brave with this because we’re moving away from familiar and comfortable territory, and we’re moving into areas where there is less measurement and there is less of an agreed currency,” he says. “We’re dealing with new vocabulary and new things and technologies. Consumers aren’t all tuning in en mass at 6 p.m. like they used to, and it’s challenging us to think about things differently. Fundamentally we have to embrace it because TV is not a dying media, but people are just consuming it in different ways, and they will consume audio visual content through screens forever. The nature of that delivery and the way that people expect brands to be around that kind of content is just going to evolve.”
Denford’s final tip for up-and-coming marketers: “Don’t be afraid to be a generalist.” He suggests learning as much as possible about all elements of the business. “If you want to be an innovator and pioneer in part of the future of the communications industry, then I think you need to have a much more 360-degree picture of the industry.” He says you also need to fundamentally understand behaviors of consumers. Part of that lies in keeping up with new technologies, reading the latest research about how consumers are using them, and doing some empirical 1st person observation. Lastly, “consume as much media as you can” and find out what people in different disciplines in your office do, he suggests.
